Cyber confidence is high, but what safeguards sit behind it?
New IAG research reveals a gap between small businesses' confidence in scam protection and the safeguards they use. What should businesses review?
Feeling protected from scams and having safeguards in place are different things. In IAG's November 2026 survey, 78% of SMEs said they were confident in their protection, yet only 52% verified invoices and payment requests and 34% trained staff to recognise scams. For business owners, the question is whether everyday procedures and insurance arrangements are keeping pace with their exposure.
Confidence and safeguards are different measures
IAG's Resilient Futures Report, released in November 2026, draws on research involving 2,600 Australian consumers and small to medium businesses.
Among the SMEs surveyed, 51% reported being targeted by scams in the previous 12 months, while 13% reported losing money or experiencing harm. Being targeted does not necessarily mean a successful cyberattack occurred, but the findings demonstrate how frequently businesses encounter attempted fraud.
Despite relatively high confidence, the reported security measures were less widespread. Only 49% used strong account security, such as multi-factor authentication, while 47% backed up business files. Staff training was reported by 34% of SMEs, and 24% used advanced cyber security tools.
Cost was the most frequently reported barrier, with 30% citing the expense of security tools. Another 26% relied on their bank for protection.
These findings come from an insurer-commissioned survey and describe what respondents reported. They do not establish the security position of any individual business.
Where the exposure sits in everyday business
Cyber risks often arise through familiar business activities: paying suppliers, exchanging documents, accessing online accounts or responding to customer emails.
IAG found that 27% of SMEs surveyed had encountered fake invoices or payment requests in the previous year, although most reported no resulting loss or harm.
The Australian Signals Directorate's Annual Cyber Threat Report 2025–26 recorded more than 82,000 cybercrime reports nationally. The average self-reported cost of cybercrime per report for small businesses was $55,400. This is not an estimate of what a typical incident will cost every business.
One exposure is payment redirection fraud. An email appearing to come from a regular supplier may instruct a business to send its next payment to different bank details. The message may use a compromised email account or convincingly imitate the supplier.
Consider a regional property agency that receives an email apparently from an established contractor advising of new bank details. The next invoice is paid. When the contractor follows up, the agency discovers that the funds were sent to an account controlled by a fraudster.
The immediate questions are operational. Who approved the payment change? Was the request verified using contact details already held by the business? When was the bank notified, and what evidence has been preserved?
Illustrative - outcomes depend on the policy held and circumstances of the claim.
AI creates opportunities and new verification challenges
Businesses are increasingly considering artificial intelligence to reduce administration and improve efficiency.
In IAG's research, 54% of SMEs agreed that AI could automate routine tasks and reduce operating costs. At the same time, 57% believed AI would increase the sophistication of scams and fraud targeting their business, while 55% were concerned about decisions based on inaccurate or misleading AI-generated information.
These are reported expectations, not measured increases in fraud.
The concern is understandable. AI tools can help fraudsters produce convincing emails, imitate writing styles and create realistic documents. Voice imitation can make some requests harder to assess.
For businesses, this reinforces the importance of verification procedures that do not depend solely on recognising suspicious wording or unusual behaviour.
A change to supplier bank details should be confirmed through a trusted contact method, using details obtained separately from the request. AI-generated financial information or customer communications should also be checked before being relied upon.
“A convincing payment request should still be verified before the money is transferred.”
What businesses should review
A useful starting point is to examine how payments are approved, particularly when supplier or payroll bank details change. Consider who can authorise changes and whether a second person verifies unfamiliar or amended instructions.
Email accounts, banking systems and business software should have appropriate access controls, including multi-factor authentication wherever available. Staff also need to understand how suspicious requests are reported and who has authority to respond.
Backups matter, particularly where a business relies on cloud accounting, property management systems or customer records. Businesses should understand how their information is stored and whether it can be restored following an incident.
Incident response arrangements deserve similar attention. If a fraudulent payment is discovered or systems become inaccessible, staff need to know whom to contact, including the bank, IT provider, broker and insurer, as relevant.
RMA Insurance Broker's guide to the first 48 hours after an incident explains why early notification, evidence preservation and documenting the circumstances can matter when an insurance claim is being assessed.
Where cyber insurance fits
Cyber security controls aim to reduce the likelihood or consequences of an incident. Cyber insurance is designed to respond to certain financial losses and expenses when an insured event occurs, subject to the policy terms.
Depending on the wording, a policy may respond to incident investigation, data restoration, business interruption, legal expenses or liability arising from a cyber event.
Fraudulent payments require particular attention. Losses arising from invoice redirection or other fraudulent instructions may be excluded, covered under an optional section, subject to a sublimit or dependent on specific verification conditions. In some cases, relevant protection may sit under a crime section in another policy.
It is also important to distinguish ordinary business interruption insurance, which generally follows insured physical damage, from cyber business interruption cover with its own triggers and conditions.
An insurance review should consider what systems the business relies on, how payments are authorised, which safeguards are in place and what the policy requires following an incident.
Our existing article on cyber insurance for Australian small businesses examines policy features, potential gaps and renewal considerations in greater detail.
If your business has changed its systems, payment procedures or use of technology, contact RMA Insurance Brokers to review whether your existing cyber insurance arrangements remain appropriate for the way you operate.
Need help understanding how this may affect your cover?
Contact the RMA Insurance Brokers team before making changes to your insurance arrangements.
Any financial product advice in this content is provided by Insura Broking Group T/as RMA Insurance Brokers AR No. 1267581. This material is general in nature and has been prepared without taking into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Accordingly, before acting on it, you should consider its appropriateness to your circumstances. RMA Insurance Brokers is an AR of McCormick Harris Insurance AFSL No. 238979.
Information is current as at the date the article is written as specified within it but is subject to change. RMA Insurance Brokers make no representation as to the accuracy or completeness of the information. Various third parties may have contributed to the production of this content. All information is subject to copyright and may not be reproduced without the prior written consent of RMA Insurance Brokers.
